Vibration fatigue analysis of components on rotating machinery under sine and sweptsineon random loading a halfpenny, f kihm, r plaskitt, hbmprenscia, technology centre, brunel way, rotherham s60 5wg, uk abstract this paper describes an approach for calculating the highcycle fatigue life of a component subjected to sineon random loading. The mean value of this ratio is near 1,0 and thus agrees with miner s rule. Use of composite vibration spectra in milstd331 fuze. Avionics structural analysis statera engineering solutions.
And then the miner damage accumulation rule is used to perform the accumulation of damage. Miner in 1945, miners rule is one of the most commonly used cumulative damage equations for failures caused by fatigue. The approach uses miners rule and a custom matlab based compositing tool to produce a set of equivalent damage potential composite transportation vibration test spectra that are economic to perform while still ensuring compliance of the fuze with the requirements of milstd331c. When a structure is excited by random vibration, the estimation on stress will provide the rms value, which is consired to be the standart deviation. The referencelife estimation is the rain owcounting method with the palmgren miner summation rule. Vibration research corporations recently introduced fatigue damage spectrum fds uses a different approach, giving engineers a reliable way to accomplish this goal by increasing system energy. Random vibration fatigue tests to prove integrity of. Tests in bending give significantly lower damage sums than tests under axial loads. Miner s rule is one of the most widely used cumulative damage models for failures caused by fatigue. Nvh and random vibration fatigue analysis of a landing. Fatigue damage for sweepsine and random accelerated vibration testing. The damage caused by one cycle is defined as d 1n f where n f is the number of repetitions of this same cycle that equals life to failure.
Cumulativedamage reliability for randomindependent normal. The damage produced by nsuch cycles is then nd nn f. This feature computes cumulative damage ratio and expected fatigue life for structures, based on the palmgren miners rule of cumulative damage ratio and materials sn fatigue curve. Highcycle fatigue life prediction for pbfree bga under. May 07, 2014 then it is necessary to calculate the number of fatigue cycles n accumulated for 1.
Now consider that the bracket assembly is subjected to the random vibration base input level shown in. Probability density function for a normal distribution. Hendersonpiersolfds is based on the principle of miners rule of damage. This feature computes cumulative damage ratio and expected fatigue life for structures, based on the palmgrenminers rule of cumulative damage ratio and materials sn fatigue curve. Miner s fatigue damage cycle ratio calculation is as follows. Random vibration analysis nastran sol 111 aerospace. Miners rule miners cumulative fatigue damage ratio is based on the idea that every stress cycle uses up part of the fatigue life of a structure, whether the stress cycle is due to sinusoidal vibration, random vibration, thermal cycling, shock or acoustic noise.
Random vibration analysis fatigue and miners cumulative damage calculation continued the corresponding miners damage calculation will use the chassis first fundamental mode for the cycle time and 3. Moreover, the calculation of the fds is carried out by considering the sn curve. Sineonrandom, sweptsineonrandom, random vibration, vibration. An efficient way of dealing with random vibrations is to use a. Finally, the chapter describes the fatigue damage generated by a swept sine vibration. The mines rules, 1955 notification new delhi, the 2nd july, 1955 s. However, it does not take into account the sequence or memory effect. Fatigue damage spectrum is random vibration spectrum based on miners rule of damage. According to the threeband technique miners rule should be used, considering three different stress levels, which are.
The method for designing pcbs for random vibration is very similar to the method used for sine vibration. Cumulative damage in fatigue with particular reference to. The identification of cycles is usually carried out through the rainflow counting method 5. Additionally, typical vibration pro les in the automotive industry are also researched. The palmgren miner linear damage rule palmgren, 1924. Fea engineering white papers predictive engineering. Cumulativedamage reliability for random independent normal or weibulldistributed fatigue stress, random fixed strength, and deterministic usage. Random vibration analysis and fatigue life evaluation. It states that if there are k different stress levels with linear damage hypothesis and the average number of cycles to failure at the ith stress, s i, is n i, then the damage fraction, c, is where. It states that if there are k different stress levels with linear damage hypothesis and the average number of cycles to failure at the ith stress, s i, is n i, then the damage fraction, c, is. When vehicles are subjected to a random vibration environment, fatigue damage may accumulate. Miner, 1945 and an sn curve following the basquin expression 1910 are employed for fatigue damage calculation under narrowband random stresses. Hassinen2 1bodycote testing group, melrose park, il 2bodycote polymer ab, nykoping, sweden abstract with the implementation of nsf protocol p171 in 1999, and subsequent adoption of astm.
When there is an irregular strain history, miner s rule can be used to determine accumulated damage and estimate the point at which failure will occur for re. The fatigue damage represented by variable d was calculated considering palmgren miner rule modified by haibach 9, where the damage content of a spectrum with size l s, is determined by the expression 20. The rainflow cycle counting rfcc, the sn curve and the miners rule are used to estimate the cumulative damage. Suppose we applied 2500 cyclic loads to the same brittle aluminum at the 150 mpa level and 500,000 cyclic loads at the 95 mpa level. A di erent approach, based on the damage mechanics of. It is called miners rule because it was popularized by m.
The study of fatigue assessment results in that data acquisition system has residual life and it can sustain random vibration loading of further 15. Just calculate the grms value and multiply it by 3. Svm1 random noise and vibration in space vehicles lyon. Sn curve, and the modified miners rule agreed with actual testing results. Use s n curve to determine fatigue life based on the vm stress. The probability pdf fi that the stress amplitude s a s a, i may occur is. To shorten these testing times an accelerated vibrationtesting appro. Goodman diagram if f u2, m u2, what is the max and min that can be applied. Uncertainty assessment of prognostics of electronics subject to random vibration jie gu, donald barker and michael pecht. Palmgren miner rule can therefore be expressed as equation 1. Random vibration here we will introduce why we do random vibration, how to understand the frequency.
Miners rule is probably the simplest cumulative damage model. Aug 29, 2019 the simcenter testlab vibration control seminar materials can be downloaded here. Various methods dirlik method, narrow band method, wirsching methodetc. Gives corrections to miners rule by use of damage vs stress ratio plots for various. Finally a random vibration fatigue test is developed at higherthanservice loads to accelerate the test and reduce. The modified miners rule is often used for fatigue evaluation of industrial machines. Extending steinbergs fatigue analysis of electronics. The linear miner s rule is the most common method used to calculate damage. Predicting fatigue failure of a circuit board in random vibration. Following is an example of an msc nastran random vibration analysis run. Synthesis of sineon random vibration profiles for accelerated life tests based. It is called miner s rule because it was popularized by m.
Palmgren miner rule provides a concept that the damage d produced by one cycle of stress is. A random vibration is one whose absolute value is not predictable at any point in time. Edwards in this report factors affecting the accuracy of miner s rule are dls cussed. Vibrationfatigue damage accumulation for structural. Question asked by mark wylie on jan 27, 2014 latest reply on feb 6, 2014 by jared conway. Fatigue life prediction for pbga under random vibration using. The summation of life consumed at each stress range must be less than 1 to avoid failure. Fatigue damage for sweepsine and random accelerated vibration testing vanjapahorkos,1 jankoslavii,2 andmihaboltedar2. Here are some relevant links from the siemens community.
A series of fatigue analysis methods have been implemented. Vibration fatigue analysis of components on rotating. Vibration fatigue calculations are ballpark calculations given. The palmgrenminer rule can be interpreted graphically as a shift of the sn curve. Miners rule teaches that fatigue damage will accumulate over time until it reaches a level that causes a crack or other deformation of a product. Palmgren miner linear law frequency psd force \ stress \ strain time random. Target audience supervisors, test engineers and technicians. Highcycle fatigue life prediction for pbfree bga under random vibration loading. Extending steinbergs fatigue analysis of electronics equipment methodology to a full relative displacement vs. If the accumulated fatigue damage reaches the limit of the material, failure will occur. Rainflow analysis and miner s cumulative damage summation for duty cycle type load spectra. Pdf the vibration testing of components in the automotive industry requires long testing times.
Cumulativedamage reliability for randomindependent normal or weibulldistributed. Number of cycles sn diagram miners rule damage from variable loadings is related to the life consumed by number of cycles at each particular stress range. Random vibrationan overview by barry controls, hopkinton, ma. Variable amplitude loading is simulated by a sequence of blocks of constant amplitudes. Newland used the definition of the number of cycles from with miners rule to calculate the accumulated fatigue damage d.
Development of a validation method for the use of miners. For example, if n 1 cycles are applied at stress level. Miners cumulative damage via rainflow cycle counting revision g by tom irvine email. Such systems must be designed and tested according. If there is no s n curve, coffinmanson equation is used to determine fatigue life.
Vibration fatigue damage accumulation for structural dynamics with nonlinearities. Fatigue damage spectrum is random vibration spectrum based on miner s rule of damage. Miners rule assumes that the damage done by each stress repetition at a given stress level is equal, meaning the first stress cycle at a uniform stress level is as damaging as the last. The rule, variously called miners rule or the palmgrenminer linear damage hypothesis, states that where there are k different stress magnitudes in a spectrum, s i 1. Testing accelerations due to random vibration at resonant frequencies in a multiple degree of freedom system can be.
Cumulative danage in fatigue with particular reference to the effects of residual stresses by p. Miners rule is one of the most widely used cumulative damage models for failures caused by fatigue. Cumulativedamage reliability for randomindependent. A comprehensive approach to fatigue under random loading. These changes have evolved from the growing awareness that random motion is the rule, rather than the exception, and from advances in electronics which.
Pdf finite element based fatigue life prediction for electronic. A component may undergo nonstationary or nongaussian random vibration. Fatigue based on random vibration solidworks forums. Jul 23, 20 miners rule is probably the simplest cumulative damage model. Figure 2 shows the amplitude time history of a random vibration. Development of a validation method for the use of miners rule in predicting the oxidative resistance of polyolefins j. The accumulated damage ead due to fatigue from random loading is based on the palmgren miner s rule, and expressed as.
Nvh and random vibration fatigue analysis of a landing gears. According to the palmgrenminer linear damage rule, failure occurs when d. With random vibration analysis, psd of stress components are and saved in d3psdcomputated. In this section, we introduce the fatigue analysis method in random vibration environment. Again, miner s rule is used for calculation of cumulative damage. A timebased model for random vibration fatigue analysis. Miles equation does not give an equivalent static load calculating the g rms value at a resonant peak after a random vibration test and multiplying it by the test article mass does not mean that the test article was subjected to that same, equivalent static load. Miners rule based on the vibrational parameters collected during the. Analyzing random vibration fatigue ansys fatigue analysis in a random vibration environment. In this analysis, the cumulative damage ratio of a landing gears leg for an unmanned aerial vehicle uav is computed using material sn stressnumber of cycles fatigue curve.
Random vibration, cumulative damage index, miners rule, fatigue assessment, data acquisition system. Mechanical structures and components may be subjected to cyclical loading conditions, including sine and random vibration. Palmgrenminer rule can therefore be expressed as equation 1. One such approach is the generalized miner s rule or the palmgren miner linear damage rule, often referred to as simply miner s rule. Random vibration an overview by barry controls, hopkinton, ma abstract. Palmgrenminer rule an overview sciencedirect topics. It simply provides a statistical calculation of the peak load for a sdof system. The presentation pdf is attached to end of the article.
Random vibration fatigue tests to prove integrity of cantilevered attachments on compressor shells j. Pdf fatigue damage for sweepsine and random accelerated. Part number 9209 vr9209 what is fatigue damage spectrum. Uncertainty assessment of prognostics of electronics. Multiaxis rainflow fatigue methods for nonstationary vibration.
This random vibration analysis is linear, which means it has linear materials and linear connections. Miner s rule miner s cumulative fatigue damage ratio is based on the idea that every stress cycle uses up part of the fatigue life of a structure, whether the stress cycle is due to sinusoidal vibration, random vibration, thermal cycling, shock or acoustic noise. An nvestlgation 1s also described of the cumulative damage behaviour of did 5014 alumlnlun alloy lug specuwns using random loading. If you cant change the design, you can do a transient structural analysis that allows for nonlinear effects to be included, like large. Fatigue damage spectrum a new tool to accelerate vibration. Multiaxis rainflow fatigue methods for nonstationary vibration t irvine dynamic concepts, inc. Frequencydomain methods for a vibrationfatiguelife. The resulting plot of fatigue damage versus frequency is the fatigue damage spectrum a means by which to quantify the stressstrain loads placed on a product. For random vibration we generally use a normal distribution for calculation of 1, 2 and 3sigma stresses, although we also sometimes use the rayleigh distribution. A damage fraction d is defined as the fraction of the life used up by an. Fatigue damage for sweepsine and random accelerated. Rainflow cycle counting is the standard method for reducing a stress time history to a table of amplitudecycle pairings prior to the palmgren miner cumulative damage calculation. Alec feinberg take our online course anytime or our webinar on feb 5th 2014 overview the 4 hour course will start with the basics, defining such terms as g, g, grms. The damage line for the modified miners rule is obtained by linearly extrapolating the sn curve into the region below the fatigue limit, as shown in figure 9.
The most popular and widely used damage summation is the palmgren miner linear damage rule, or miners rule, discussed in section 9. Fatigue damage spectrum theory miners rule of damage says that fatigue damage accumulates. The fatigue damage spectrum is based on miners rule of damage that indicates fatigue damage accumulates for a product until a life. Cumulative damage in fatigue with particular reference to the. Miner s rule teaches that fatigue damage will accumulate over time until it reaches a level that causes a crack or other deformation of a product. Alec feinberg take our online course anytime or our webinar on feb 5th 2014.
Miners fatigue damage cycle ratio calculation is as follows. Miners rule simply states that the failure occurs when the summation of the individual damage values caused by each rainflow cycle reaches a value of 1. Miners rule operates on the hypothesis that the portion of useful fatigue life used up by a number of repeated stress cycles. Spectrum analysis specified for random vibration, as the second step, was performed. In this article, we will explain what it is and how it is related to other more advanced cumulative damage models in alta. Highcycle fatigue life prediction for pbfree bga under random vibration loading da yua, abdullah alyafawia, tung t. This should include, the wiley titles, and the specific portion of the content you wish to reuse e. Miners rule is obtained through the production of an sn curve. In this article, we will explain what it is and how it is related to other more advanced cumulative damage models in. The palmgrenminer cumulative rule is applied to calculate the fatigue life. Comparisons among the proposed method, dirliks solution, nonlinear model in literature, and the experimental data, are carried out.
The modified miners rule is a simple way to account for the effect of stresses below the fatigue limit. Apply miner s rule to calculate cdi cumulative damage index 2 for random vibration. The same equation can be used for the maximum allowable displacement. Miner linear damage rule an overview sciencedirect topics. These formulas have been used in many practical applications 58. For the experiment an electrodynamic shaker with a vibration controller was used. As opposed to sinusoidal vibration, there is no well defined periodicity the amplitude at any point in time is not related to that at any other point in time. C is the fraction of life consumed by exposure to the cycles at. Cycle distribution in random loadings hu,v joint pdf cdf u v h. Does fatigue life take into account the damage from vibrations. A symmetric nongaussian random vibration can be decomposed into a series of gaussian. To use miners method, an sn curve, also called a stresslife model is required.
88 1083 224 924 713 514 1151 1244 78 73 17 1239 1320 452 909 918 1312 410 1173 33 1352 1184 1168 1052 630 1093 72 1484 496 435 1309 142 812 989 893 217 1237 1102 702 185 284